Yes, I am the last Trek fan to see the new Trek reboot. I had high hopes on this since I like JJ Abrahms work in general (I am a huge fan of Lost) and heard mostly good things. I was kinda blowing off the supernerds poo-pooing things, because that is just what supernerds do.
And I have to say--I am a little disappointed.
It was a pretty movie, and I thought the casting was REALLY REALLY well done (in particular, Spock, Scotty and McCoy.) They did a good job and hardly thought of the original cast--they did incorporate the mannerisms of TOS characters well without making them look overt. Reallly. Well. Done.
Yeah, the story was a little frothy, and that's fine. A lot of Trek movie plots fall down when you look at them too closely, and this was better than most of them (I am still willing to have installment 5 scrubbed from my brain) So as a chunk of entertainment, I think this was fine, and I think if you've never seen an episode of Star Trek, you'd enjoy this MORE than a fan, which is quite a trick to pull of in a franchise movie.
But MAN. I do not know how I feel on what is, essentially, a movie that has taken on the mythology of the WHOLE THING and erased it. Changed the ways in which these characters relate to each other in a couple places. A Kirk who came to Star Fleet because he was inspired by his dad is surely a different person than one who was arm twisted into it (and really, now I'm thinking it too much, and I don't see why a young JTK would have gotten on board that shuttle given what we are shown of his youth)
So...this is Alternate Reality Trek. Its not a retelling on what we know about these character's backstory. I don't think this is necessarily bad--we've seen snips and glimpses of alternate realities on all the flavors of Trek, and exploring those worlds could be fun. I am just not sure how I feel on it yet, but I guess if I can think that First Crew is off doing its thing (and having Checkov show up mid journey instead of present on deck right away) and this is just another path that could have been I'll be happier about it.